Exile & the First Triumvirate
History could have been different had Cicero accepted Caesar’s invitation to join himself, Pompey and Crassus in what later became known as the First Triumvirate. He declined on the grounds that the alliance was unconstitutional. His past came back to haunt him when in 58 BC, Publius Clodius became Tribune. He was an enemy of Cicero ever since the orator spoke against him during Clodius’ trial for profanity in 61 BC. Cicero knew he was in trouble and when Pompey refused to help, he fled Rome. The following day, Clodius carried a bill that forbade the execution of a Roman citizen without trial. Then he carried another bill that said Cicero was an exile.
Cicero eventually returned with the help of Pompey in 57 BC and tried to steer his ally away from Caesar with no success. Pompey renewed his pact with Caesar and Crassus at Luca in 56 BC. Cicero agreed to align himself with the Triumvirate in politics, but this meant defending some disreputable characters. After completing famous written works such as On the Orator, On the Republic and On Laws, he failed in his defense of Milo in 52 BC when his client was accused of murdering Clodius. He governed the province of Cilicia in 51 BC and was praised for ruling with integrity.
Civil War
When he returned to Rome, Caesar and Pompey were in a battle for supremacy and Cicero was on the outskirts of the city when Caesar famously crossed the Rubicon in January 49 BC. He met both men, and during a discussion with Caesar in March, Cicero told the great commander of his intention to speak against Caesar’s conflict with Pompey in the Senate. As much as he hated the idea of Caesar’s dictatorship, he knew that the commander’s enemies would kill him if they triumphed! Cicero spent the next couple of years completing another collection of written works.
Cicero had no involvement in Caesar’s assassination on March 15, 44 BC nor was he in the Senate when it happened. By now, he saw Mark Antony as a threat, and his 14 Philippic Orations against his new enemy were designed to get the Senate to declare war against Caesar’s former lieutenant. At some point, Cicero spoke out against Octavian by stating the young man should be disposed of when his usefulness had expired. The future emperor learned of these comments and after he had formed the Second Triumvirate with Mark Antony and Lepidus, Cicero’s days were numbered.
The End
When the Triumvirate began proscribing their enemies, Cicero’s name was one of the first on the list, and he was aggressively pursued. Eventually, a centurion named Herennius and a tribune named Popilius found him in a villa at Formiae on December 7, 43 BC. Cicero had hoped to catch a ship to Macedonia to escape his enemies, but the two assassins caught him, and Herennius stabbed him before cutting off the orator’s head. Fulvia, the wife of Mark Antony, pulled out Cicero’s tongue and stabbed it with a hairpin. Antony ordered Cicero’s head and hands to be pinned to the Rostra in the Forum Romanum.
Cicero was a ‘new man,’ a phrase that referred to someone with no noble ancestry. As a result, the Optimates never accepted him into their circle. Unlike so many other men of the era, Cicero was prepared to compromise his ideals for the good of the Republic, but in the end, he was unable to do anything as it crumbled and was replaced by an Empire.